Weekly Contest Results - August 21st

  • Meena Krish
    6 years ago, updated 6 years ago

    Hello Everyone! This week we have a variety of poems been showcased by
    many talented poets. Congrats to the front page Winners-mossgirl19,
    hiraeth and Ben P and congrats to all who received a HM! Well done poets!
    Thank you judges for your time and effort!
    Here are the awaited comments.

    WINNERS:

    Moonlight Drawn by Clouds by mossgirl19

    to you dear poets by hiraeth

    A thousand miles per hour round the sun by Ben Packard

    COMMENTS:

    Moonlight Drawn by Clouds by mossgirl19

    Mel (like most people here) has a very unique style and this piece is no different and
    is in my opinion by far one of her best pieces I've read. It distinctively speaks of the
    patience we need when dealing with a long distance relationship and the questioning
    of why in some instances their day is our night and vice versa but it shows there's no
    greater love than the one Mel speaks of and to her it's one of real love which shows
    throughout the piece. A beautiful image is brought out through her words,
    bravo. (10 points)
    ----------------------------------------------
    to you dear poets by hiraeth

    Mark has this way of writing that's unique and very profound but which
    resonates with the best of us here on this site which is why I couldn't overlook this
    poem when reading it without giving it the recognition it deserved. We can all relate
    to this poem on where our poetry originates from - did we start writing to help someone
    through their pain because we've known pain all our lives, did we write because poetry
    is 'in our blood', do we write for fun or is it because poetry is the only help we ourselves
    have or is it just because in English class we read a poem that we thought "wow I wish
    I could write like that one day" too. Mark says it all but in a much better way than I
    ever could. (7 points)
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    To You Dear Poets by Hiraeth

    I found this to be a rather beautiful poem that captivated me completely from
    the outset. That it is an acknowledgement of the work of others is lovely
    gesture but this is not the reason for my vote.

    I gave my vote due to its structure and flow, also because of the colorful
    and wonderful visuals contained within.

    Thank you for the smiles (4 points)
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    to you dear poets by hiraeth

    This is the stuff. I wish I had words and I so desperately want to give this
    poem the proper comment but every time I pick apart and piece through, I only
    feel like I can 'breathe'. An ode to fellow poets, those of us who get one another
    even if we truly don't, in that longing desire and understanding. The nooks and
    crannies of the palms - so tender and gentle yet fierce. I loved every single bit of
    this poem, and hope it gets highlighted on the front page for everyone to see.
    Beautiful, beautiful stuff. (10 points)
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    to you dear poets" by: hiraeth

    I feel like a giddy child reading this poem. What I've found with your poems,
    especially this one, is that they have an individuality and come to life before my eyes.
    It's like an interactive storybook from my imagination.

    Too often I find poems that are so reliant on explaining, with heavy details that
    seem to weigh the poem down. But here, I find light. It's like you've let me step outside
    for a breath of fresh air, and everything feels new to me.

    Bravo! You've given poems their own pathways and words their own land to grow
    on.

    I can't help but sigh at that last line.... poets truly breathe life into this often
    dreary, meaningless world. (10 points)
    --------------------------------------------

    A thousand miles per hour round the sun(bowlesian sonnet) by Ben Packard

    Another incredible piece of poetry sees Mr Packard nominated once
    again and rightfully so.

    This work has a wonderful tempo and kept me bobbing along with it.
    I also enjoyed the message it conveys.Sometimes things can't be mapped out for
    us and indeed I think we all need to get a little lost sometimes. Only by getting lost
    do we truly find ourselves.

    Well done (10 points)
    -----------------------------------------------------

    HM’s:

    A Sonnet for Shakespeare by Ben Pickard

    Battlefield of Fear *sonnet* by Kasie

    Unwanted Treasure by Maple Tree

    Failings" By Brenda

    Shotgun by Hope

    Went on our Way by Lucifer

    A Book with a Filthy Cover by Maple Tree

    Drink! by Mark points

    Scattering seeds by Britt

    COMMENTS:

    Shotgun by Hope

    "mortal sin burns in these veins"

    - I LOVE the mention of mortal sins, not in a sinister way so to speak but I love
    how it adds depth and almost a fear. Growing up religiously, my childlike self was
    always aware of how grave, how serious mortal sins were. I was reminded and warned
    about "eternal damnation" and "everlasting punishment".

    "you're mine for catastrophic faith"

    - The punch and impact of your lines is incredible. This feels so darkly intimate
    and like your voice keeps reminding how you won't just go away. You may fade, but
    there's almost this endless fate that can't be escaped.

    I liked the intrigue and mystique of this poem (not to mention the rhythm), how
    I kept pondering things like, if you are haunting this person to protect them? That
    if you make one mistake in you guarding them, their life will be at stake. The dead
    DO talk and in this poem, it's like that love is keeping you awake, that even love cannot
    be caught or trapped by death.

    My only criticism (and this is based on my opinion and personal preference) is that I
    felt you used too much punctuation in places. Since you had an obvious break when
    going to the next line, I almost could say you didn't need the comma after every
    line. (7 points)
    ----------------------------------------------------
    Drink! by Mark

    Mark has put his all into this piece about (in my opinion) a public house atmosphere
    and it's very well rhymed and I think somewhat fun. I love the pace of the lines. I
    appreciate the repetition because most drunks do repeat things, it's not something
    you see everyday but it hit the spot. (4 points)
    ------------------------------------------

    Failings by Brenda

    I found this to be a quite harrowing poem to read that triggered a lot of
    thought and emotion within myself and yet it pulls you in completely.
    Such emotion and frustration so effectively and fluently voiced, you can't
    escape it, although some of it makes your heart bleed.

    I can only imagine what it's like, not being able to bond with a family member,
    but from what is described within I can easily see how this would be the case.

    The last stanza actually got an audible "NO" from my lips. You are not failing,
    you're doing everything you can from what I perceive. That some people refuse to
    help themselves is unfortunately a fact of life.

    Incredibly well written and conveyed (7 points)
    ------------------------------------------------

    Went on our Way by Lucifer

    Reminiscing bygone days of love is something every one of us can relate to.
    Think of something so beautiful laid to waste. I love the loving tone of the
    piece. With excellent word choice the writer was able to effectively portray
    how beautiful this love was once was. I think of a kind of love that didn’t
    work out but undoubtedly has taught the speaker here so much.
    I also love the unique rhyme scheme used in here. A great scheme that
    allowed the piece to flow so well. Wonderful job! (4 points)
    -----------------------------------------------
    Battlefield of Fear *sonnet* by Kasie

    Sonnets are metered, and they are expected to flow well. The great
    challenge here is always the word choice in expressing the thoughts in
    each line. Kasie did an excellent job here, as this one did not only impart an
    inspiring message but is also absolutely seamless. This does her
    mentors proud! (7 points)
    ------------------------------------------------
    A Sonnet for Shakespeare by Ben Pickard

    An excellently - crafted tribute to who may be considered as the greatest
    writer of all time. Shakespeare is a literary genius! What I get from this
    piece is the fact that, the power of poetry spans many generations and what
    more can poets ever dream of, than create masterpieces that will outlive them!
    Long gone but this Bard is still inspiring millions of poets around the world.

    Though the writer here claims he cannot make the grade…he has his
    own unique take at sonnets that undoubtedly will do Shakespeare
    proud. (10 points)
    ----------------------------------------------
    Unwanted Treasure by Maple Tree

    A poem that many writers can understand and feel on some level - we
    have these words and thoughts and feelings and desires buried deep in our
    hearts and minds and they just beg, ache to come out. I love the part about even
    in pages of poetry there is secrets and lies. I know that holds so true for me,
    what we wish we felt, what we wish we could heal, and even holding back the
    true despair we hold in our hands. This is a beautiful piece of art, one that is
    important to evaluate ourselves in. (7 points)
    ----------------------------------------------

    A Book with a Filthy Cover by Maple Tree

    A beautiful yet haunting piece, and I can tell this poem is laced
    with so much anguish, so incredibly personal. Beautiful work.
    (4 points)
    -----------------------------------------------

    scattering seeds by Britt

    I was actually just reading some poem I randomly came across online that
    used the word "ooze" and it made me physically cringe. But here, it works somehow.
    It's more direct and I feel the goodness deep in the soil and rooted in her
    story.

    The part that especially resonated with me was: "she thumbs over the dirt and her
    hurt" and it's almost like this fear of the unknown, of a greater plan, one that is
    just being revealed to you that you cannot plan for. As usual, I find a lot of spirituality
    and personal awakening in your poetry.

    Your theme of growth (both personally, spiritually and literally in regards to
    mother earth) has been prominent in your other poems... and I applaud you for
    sharing your voice and journey. (4 points)

  • Brenda
    6 years ago

    Congratulations to all the front page winners and HM's. Once again this amazing week of writing. Thank you judges for your wonderful comments on my poem, I greatly appreciate your kind words. Ben, thank you for nominating this piece. Meena, thank you for hosting.

  • mossgirl19
    6 years ago, updated 6 years ago

    I'd like to thank our judges for the wonderful comment on 'moonlight' not quite expecting the win but happy that it did as it was just raw... and my genuine feelings towards a long distant loved one. ;-)

    It's an honour to be up there with Ben and Mark. Thank you Craig for the nomination. Congratulations to everyone and thank you Ms. Meena for hosting.

    Another great week! :-)

  • Kasie
    6 years ago

    Thank you judges for the wonderful comment on my poem. Also, congratulations to the front page winners and to my fellow hm's. We have some very talented poets!

  • Lucifer
    6 years ago, updated 6 years ago

    Congratulations, to all the winners of weekly contest and those who got HM's including me.
    A big thanks to Brenda and Em for nominating my poems.
    I am grateful to the judges for considering one of my poem worth the HM and even more grateful to that one particular judge who gave such wonderful comment about it.

    Thanks to all the judges for their valuable time and appreciating our work.

  • Ben Pickard
    6 years ago, updated 6 years ago

    Thank you again to the judges for their time and congratulations to all those highlighted this week.

  • Britt
    6 years ago

    Thank you sweet judge for the HM <3 Thanks Meena and mods and judges for all your work, and congrats to winners & HMs!

    (I always feel like an awkward broken record posting this every week lol)

  • Maple Tree
    6 years ago

    Thank you judges, very kind and thoughtful comments

    Congratulations to everyone!

  • Em
    6 years ago

    I'm a tad late but congratulations all - thanks judges and Meena

  • Larry Chamberlin replied to Em
    6 years ago, updated 6 years ago

    Congratulations to the winners and HMs.
    Thanks, Meena for Hosting and to the judges..