Comments : Sculpture and trees nurture.

  • 18 years ago

    by Dorotea©

    A truly breathtaking piece with a bit of sadness to it. Truly beautiful descriptions you used here.

    "the misery of frost on it's branches"

    This line, alone, was already very nicely said and my favorite from this piece.

    In the beginning of the poem, you used "too," when I think you meant "to." I just wanted to point that out. This poem was very nice, and though the flow could use some more work, I liked it a lot.

    Dorotea (and, by the way, thanks for your comment on my poem. I appreciate it a lot...and thanks for the critique :)

  • 18 years ago

    by Shædow Poet

    Ah... firstly I gotta offer some grammatical help:
    "Began the growth of a tree,
    from acorn, too spout, too root,
    too stem and then too leaf,
    fresh and young it grew
    strongly, well nurtured,
    well kept at least
    at first."
    EVERY 'too' in that was wrong. It should have been 'to'. If you want to email me and maybe i can tell you why. Trust me, I use to struggle with 'to' and 'too' also. Also, you may want to check your "it's" and "its" I saw a few wrong. Remember "it's" is short for "it is".
    But, apart from that, i LOVED it. you used such AMAZING description. "the image of a girl of angelic looks", there were some delicately crafted stanzas. From start to finish, you kept me intrigue.
    Just watch out for a few minor mistakes ;)
    Apart from that, I loved it! You're AMAZING for your age.

  • 18 years ago

    by Sean

    Thank you both, made the changes now and it's been extremly useful :)

  • 18 years ago

    by Shædow Poet

    Sean: I hope you don't mind, but I am going to add you on my favourite's list.

  • 18 years ago

    by Sean

    You were added to mine a long, long time ago. :)

    So, no i don't mind.

  • 18 years ago

    by Marjan

    beautifully written. you're really talented.

  • 18 years ago

    by EoB

    As Marjan cared to tell you, a beautiful piece of poetry. Original as hell...

    Creative...To use a tree and a sculpture was simply brilliant.,

    Your descriptions are wonderful, and to make such a good poem at your age is most remarkable...

    I thought I was the youngest of the serious writers...

    keep it up man...

    I'm sorry if this wasn't to much help, but I have one hell of a hangover...

  • 18 years ago

    by Sean

    Thank you, Enslavement. :)