It all started the day I got that voicemail
"Hey Kaitlynn this is Andy...

You held me one last time
You tell me what I don't want to hear...

Why does it have to be like this?
This just isn't fair...

The last night of the church retreat
You slipped me your phone number...

They say don't worry about you
that in two weeks I'll be on to someone new...

You were my first love
Because of you I now know...