Constructive Criticism

  • Spirit
    17 years ago

    I am tired of getting nice little happy notes for comments on my poems I am looking for someone to tell me whats wrong with my poems what you don't like. that way I can improve and strive to be better. I'm not saying that I'll listen to or care about you adivice I'm just saying that I'm tired of happy little nothing (wow ___&___ were such good lines and ___ was a good idea. your flow was off but I could still feel your meening) no that dosen't count.

    Rules:
    -The more helpful I find your Criticism the better(personal rule)
    -Don't talk about the flow, spelling, grammer, or anything else like that. (I know that that is bad and I've been working on it don't remind me!)(please)
    -I would rather you leave titles. You don't have to unless you want to be rrc.
    -No liners I don't care why you wrote the poem
    -Don't worry about your words hurting my feelings I'm a big girl I can take it.
    -For every 1 of mine you do I'll do 1 of yours
    -You must read/rate/comment the entire thing.
    -Oh and please no poems are unsuitable

    Thank you for your help you can choose from these titles

    -Guilt
    -Not so Perfect
    -The Last Day
    -Ode to a Teenager
    -Duct Taped Mind
    -Hell
    -A Behind the Scenes Thank You
    -Two Teachers
    -Bubbles

  • Courageous Dreamer
    17 years ago

    I did four of yours.

    I tried giving you any thoughts that crossed my mind and how you could make the poem better. I'm sorry if I wasn't too detailed on my suggestions.

    Please do;
    "Love is a mystery..Solve it."
    "Accident or Murder?"
    "Ocean View"
    "Taking that Leap of Faith."

    Thanks in Advance.!

  • H E Losey
    17 years ago

    If one critiques your words and follows this rule:
    "Don't talk about the flow, spelling, grammer, or anything else like that." and I'm sure rhyme is included, then how can you know what needs to be improved?

  • H E Losey
    17 years ago

    After reading a few of your writes I see why you don't want any one to talk about spelling, grammar, rhythm, misused words, punctuation or anything dealing with language arts.....you have no command of these.

  • Spirit
    17 years ago

    -Leap Of Faith aka Temps
    thanks for your poems
    it was inspiring

    -H E losey
    do you have any poems you want read?

  • Courageous Dreamer
    17 years ago

    Thank you, I appreciate the comments.

  • Spirit
    17 years ago

    Anyone else?

  • Spirit
    17 years ago

    Thank you Rikki

    please let me know
    which poem you want me to rrc

  • Spirit
    17 years ago

    Thank you Rikki

    that poem was beautiful

    anyoun else