3 guys

You're making it obvious that the one that you love doesn't want to date you; So I wouldn't even put him as an option. You're only setting yourself up for 'heart break'. I'd say go with the one you haven't dated, you have to give all of them a try :] If it doesn't work, there's TONSSS of boys. You just have to give him a chance. As for the one that cheated on you, screw him, and don't feel bad. He was willing to put your feelings on the line, so yeah.x

Well don't date the on that dumped you for another girl, you're kinda making it sound like he doesn't want to date you.
Don't date the one who cheated on you, like I say once a cheater always a cheater... for the most part.
So date the one you Haven't dated yet. Just becuase he isn't your type and you've dated someone like him before doesn't mean it won't work. If you wanna give him a chance then give him one. And don't doubt yourself.

ok go for the nerd

it's pretty obvious one guy dumped you for another chick whats to say he won't again and the other one cheated on you. so basically the first and second guys are pricks and the 3rd sounds most likely to treat you like a human being

to be honest with you i don't think you should go out with any of them. You don't sound up to going out with any of them if this makes sense. there are tons more fish in the sea, go out to one your attracted to.

I'd say go for the one you haven't dated. That's what you were gonna do first, right? Then don't let another guy who has previously broken your heart keep you from taking a chance with this guy.

I wouldn't go back to the second guy. One of my bestest friends went out with this guy who cheated on her, so they broke up, but she took him back on the promise that he would never do it again. And he did. They broke up again. And this went on about 4 or 5 times until finally she just broke up with him for good. I'm not saying that this will happen to everyone, but a lot of times it does.

You also have a fourth choice. It's called not dating. If you're confused about who you want to go out with, then maybe you shouldn't date either of them, because if you're having feelings for one but go out with another that's not really fair to them or you.

Basically, just follow your heart. And don't compromise your beliefs for any boy and don't do anything that you don't want to do. Just listen to yourself.