Comments : Comatose (Zanila Rhyme)

  • 14 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    Wow, I have never heard of this form before, thank you for sharing it with us and explaining it's rules.

    "Entwined - battered black steel, shattered glass,"

    Love the descriptions that really grab me and pull me in. Loved the alliteration: "battered black", that was unique and new to me.

    "fathomlessly silent night;"

    I liked the way you used "fathomlessly" in this piece, I had to look up the word, I really don't hear it often. It fit really well here though, once I found the meaning.

    "Over grown with fog and putrid bog
    suffocating all that's bright and light."

    This is so striking to the reader, what vivid imagery you have created and described. Your poems never seem to amaze me, your wording is always so fresh and unique, never cliche or boring.

    "Breaking silence, feet step in morass"

    I loved "breaking silence", that just really got me.

    "exemplifying the site:"
    putrid bog and over grown with fog,
    lifeless or alive; a daunting night."

    Again, great wording, so descriptive and real and intense.

    "Reaching a bitter end, an impasse"

    I looked up "impasse" and I really liked how you used it here, instead of using such a common word, you really made the reader think.

    "vanished into the bleak night."

    Very dark, great job Joe so far, your poetry is simply beautiful and impressive.

    "Over grown with fog and putrid bog
    lies the primitive burial sites."

    What an ending, I re-read this quite a bit and you did such a great job with the title. The ending was powerful and left the reader still pondering all that you said.

    5/5 from me, a thoughtful read, thanks for posting, its always a pleasure.

    Take care and God bless you.

    ~MaryAnne

  • 14 years ago

    by Cindy

    Wow Joe.....what a form.....confussing to me :)
    You did a excellent job mastering it. Very deep dark and intense. Great imagery and word choices. I got chills when reading parts of your piece.
    take care
    Cindy

  • 14 years ago

    by Nee

    Oh I LOVE this!
    First of all, thank you for introducing this beautiful form, honestly I haven't heard of it before.

    Well done with the rhyme, it was so beautiful and flowed spontaneously and intelligently!

    I loved this Joe :) Thank you for sharing.
    Write on~

  • 14 years ago

    by Meme

    Aamazing poem
    N thanx for the tip
    I never heard of this form before

  • 14 years ago

    by The Prince

    Good job on the form, Joe, though your consistent use of polysylabbics makes this piece lack communication and direction. I'm not going to pick it apart but I've noticed this in your recent writes that you're trying too hard and as a result, your narration is suffering. You're using too much high frequency lexis, and unrealising that sometimes it becomes clumsy. Not your best piece by far, I didn't think it had significant direction, nor any beginning, middle, or end. With this form, too, that relies on syllable count, why fill it up with words that don't really add anything?
    Exemplifying - 5 syllables, yet seems out of place, do you see what I mean?

    'suffocating all that's bright and light.'

    This doesn't really make much sense either. Try to read over your poems with a different eye, something that makes sense to you might make no sense to someone else. Try to refrain from the overuse of these big words, focus on your communication, which is your weakest aspect, and probably the weakest aspect of most amateur poets like all of us on this site.

  • 14 years ago

    by Courageous Dreamer

    I figured I would comment on this sense nobody else is joining my contest. :)

    'Entwined - battered black steel, shattered glass,'
    `You have a unique way of writing, you still get the point across that these two objects are entwined, but you phrase it different then most people would. I liked that. This line was really interesting.. how the two are entwined, they are mixed together, I'm guessing something bad happened, resulting in the steel and shattered glass.

    'Over grown with fog and putrid bog
    suffocating all that's bright and light.'
    `Loved the usage of suffocating, at first I couldn't really see that image, but suffocating itself has a big effect and I can see how thick this fog is, suffocating brings forth an image in my mind that is very vivid.

    'exemplifying the site:'
    `Loved exemplifying, very good word choice.

    'putrid bog and over grown with fog,'
    `You did a brilliant job at this line, the one that needed to have an internal rhyme and then be reversed for the even stanza. It makes just as much sense written in reverse.

    'Reaching a bitter end, an impasse'
    `Impasse -I dont think Ive ever really even heard that word, lol.. thanks for teaching me something new. :)

    'lies the primitive burial sites.'
    `Loved the dark images throughout and the ending toped it all off nicely.

    A great great job. You are the master of this form, you did a brilliant job. It looked difficult, but you managed to pull it off very nicely. Well done!