Comments : Grandpa

  • 12 years ago

    by Decayed

    Omg Rania.. this is so tearing and heart aching..

    It's a rush of emotions.
    Like the same play I watched in LAU, Beirut....

    I twas really moving.. flawlessly described.

    You just brought the whole ER in here, with all the cries and the tears.. all the pain and fear of losing someone this close..

    where I've saw you the last time,
    ^ where I've "SEEN"..

    It flowed so great, and you just can move mountains with your alive words.. They dash hastily, without any sound,, or any interruption!!

    AMAZZZZZZZINGGG

    Definitely nominated the next week..

    I wonder if you're still there
    where I've saw you the last time,
    waiting on a lifeless bed, almost
    as motionless as you were in hope
    to hear my final words, [still ?]
    as I break down at the feet of a farewell...
    You know like a stranger who's too
    afraid to lose a path that's already missing.

    ^ Rania,,, you're so amazing.. It's like the voice of Rafic Hariri's wife ... ( I don't know.. but I love her damn voice when she talks..)..

    A333
    it's just so awesome to continue talking..

    5/5
    definitely winning to me :')

  • 12 years ago

    by Meme

    It's coming up soon, the day you passed
    I
    didn't say goodbye, no I don't think I did
    and it is hard not to, but Pa trust me
    it's too damn harder to do.
    ^^
    Why is the "I" by itself, is it meant to be left like that? I think it should be with the next line.

    The second verse was when I broke into tears. I can barely remember my grandpa, he passed away when I was ten, but I sometimes dream of him, and sometimes remember some bits and pieces of my childhood when he used to race me into eating those big slices of watermelon. Ohh how I miss you grandpa :(

    Final goodbyes are the hardest things to do, and I too haven't got the chance to say goodbye, but I still remember what happened, he asked for a glass of water saying he is thirsty, when my aunt went to bring him some, she came back to find him resting there lifeless. Everytime mom tells me this story I get chills and start crying.

    Grandpa, may your soul rest in peace.

  • 12 years ago

    by Innocent Fairy

    I like this though it's sad in 1/2 ways I can relate :) I'm sorry 4 their loss... 5/5

  • 12 years ago

    by Courageous Dreamer

    Brought a tear to my eye. It's hard to remember that night, it's still something very vivid to me. You're one of the greatest people I know, what a huge heart you have to write a poem for someone after hearing how they are feeling without being asked. It seems to ease the sadness really when someone can express it perfectly in a poem. It's nice to know someone cares, and is there to provide comfort and support. This poem definitely has a spot in my heart, always will. ;)

  • 12 years ago

    by nouriguess

    Well, though we had a fight, Rania and I was trying to avoid your profile and....your poems and everything, I couldn't help it! I wanted to check out this piece because the title was truly "simplebutcatchy". I right away decided to leave a comment, even though it will be useless maybe or makes no sense, lol but I just wanted to let you know that I was touched and impressed to the core with this write, I almost cried, remembering my mother, who passed away many years ago, I remembered how awful it is to leave the ER room without saying "the last goodbye" :'( I wasn't able for I was a baby :/ I didn't know I'll be an orphan! ok, lol I am talking about something irrelevant, ok I'll stop :)
    You should know that losing someone is really a hard thing to live with but remembering the memories together is harder and having no memory with them is the hardest thing...ever. Tell me about it! lol :) I was asking myself and ponderig "how did this little smart cat write this when she is not the one who lost a grandpa!?"
    I'll give you the date when my mother died, will you write me too? :)

    Anyways, I'll only talk about the piece! I promise, haha.

    The opening was intelligent, I've always liked your opening stanzas because they draw me in, in no time. I only find myself leaving a nonsensial comment describing my 'wow'! :P

    Time's been like a tornado
    fleeting through my fingers yet
    inflicting damage to my heart.
    ^^^
    I so loved the metaphor here, Rania, time is really relentless...and so are your metaphors (in a good way:P)

    Left you in the ER room, not saying
    Goodbye and oh how hard it is not to.
    I wonder if you're still there
    where I've seen you the last time,
    waiting on a lifeless bed, almost
    as motionless as you were in hope
    to hear my final words, [still ?]
    as I break down at the feet of a farewell...
    You know like a stranger who's too
    afraid to lose a path that's already missing.
    ^^^
    Jeezzzzzzeee
    I have tears and chills, I'm inspired at the moment like never before! I feel "wtf?"....god my oh!
    the questioning [still?] made LOTS of sense to me, as if you're asking if he is still hearing your words or so, right?? I felt it.

    It's coming up soon, the day you passed
    I
    didn't say goodbye, no I don't think I did
    and it is hard not to, but Pa trust me
    it's too damn harder to do.
    ^^^
    I agree with Meme about the "I", it seems weird, a bit.

    In all, this was a write that will be right away added to my favorite, a write that will be memorable for a very long while, a write that I'll re-read and re-re-read. :) Good job.

  • 12 years ago

    by Mushh

    This is beautiful <3 5/5

  • 12 years ago

    by Larry Chamberlin

    Wonderful tribute to a man who obviously meant much to you. It is also a powerful self-analysis triggered by your inability to say goodby. Your emotions, bottled up so long, explode out like the tornado to which you refer.
    Your integrity is the most powerful thing about the undercurrent. You admit there was no final words of comfort, that you broke "down at the feet of a farewell." Yet you put it quite simply: saying goodbye is more difficult than living with the failure to do so. Your awareness that you walk the razor's edge is evident, powerful and a mark of maturity.

  • 12 years ago

    by Britt

    This poem was a bit harder read for me, maybe because the emotion and it brought my own thoughts and feelings of the death of relationships in my life. It wasn't easy for me to get through.

    One thing -- why is goodbye in the second stanza capitalized? On purpose? I thought it was a tad distracting, unless you have a purpose for that :)