Comments : My Brother (The Milk Boy)

  • 10 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    I read this yesterday and didn't know quite how to comment.... now, I'm sitting here thinking, why has no one else commented?

    This was very interesting for me to read and I like how you tied your thoughts in together. Seemed like it could be a poem, but that you didn't focus on structure or flow, just on the memory itself. Loved how clearly I could picture this, and I like how you both, so young, are connected through this milk run. Almost like he is your guardian now because you aren't old enough to be on your own, especially going to chapel and having this routine together.

    I have a few scenes in my head that come back to me or memories I never really probed before, but when I relive it in my mind, I realize things I never took time to think about before.

    Also got a strong sense of the mind of a child, choosing between right and wrongs, and little delights like baked bread or fresh cold milk in a jar, what that would mean... you and your brother are tempted, but continue on with the rumbling stomachs, knowing right now you don't have the cents to pay for them.

    Neat write Hellon, glad you could share!

  • 10 years ago

    by Baby Rainbow

    My brother had a milk run
    at the age of eight...
    that would make me
    five years old and yet...
    I was left on guard
    of his cart as he ran up
    three flights of stairs
    to place the ordered bottles
    at each door...

    - my first thought after reading the opening was just how much things have changed, children used to be safer out on the streets and even in the care of not much older siblings and relatives. This straight away set the time period for me, compared to now where it feels like children are unsafe to be unattended anywhere! I think it also shows how much children helped back then with work, to contribute to the family.

    People were desperate back then
    and would take the milk if
    left...I was five years old
    what was I possibly going to do?

    - Again I think this shows the different way of life back then, I mean to think of someone being desperate for milk, that wouldn't happen much now in working families, we consider it a basic need now a days. I also like how you portray yourself as this tiny little girl that would not know a thing about protecting herself, or the milk, yet somehow it seemed to keep thieves away.

    The bakery also delivered back then
    and...while I was waiting (and guarding)
    my tummy would rumble
    at the smell of freshly baked rolls
    also being delivered

    but...I couldn't steal them
    much as I wanted to!

    - I adore the scene I got here, somehow it took me to Italy, but perhaps because I always imagine fresh made bread and bakeries in this country. I can imagine the smell of fresh bread making you feel really hungry and giving you temptations to steal just a tiny piece!

    It was a sin to steal...and

    we had to go to chapel
    right after the milk was
    delivered...

    - I like how you set the daily routine here and describe to the reader exactly how it was, I think this is really important here because religion doesn't seem to be important in many countries any more.

    My brother, having made his
    first communion
    had to fast for three hours
    to be able to have the
    body of Christ
    I was too young for that
    but
    I, came out on his side
    and fasted too
    I was five years old...

    - I would change the comma here, remove it from after I, and place it instead after too.

    and...

    as we finally put the cart
    at the back of the co-op shop
    he tried his best to re-tie
    the sash on the back of my dress
    and we went into chapel together
    both with growling tummies...

    - this made me think of how obedient children were then, compared to now, I don't imagine for a second they would have complained to anyone about their hunger or that that would throw any sort of tantrum like you would see now.

    I remember the priest
    looking at my polished
    but scuffed shoes
    with a certain disdain
    then holding my gaze

    and...

    As my eyes lowered
    I knew he had guessed
    we had no pennies for
    the plate...

    - nice way to end, reinforcing the message of just how scarce money was back then and how the family would see even bread and milk as a luxury to be able to have.

    I do enjoy your poems that make you think of different generations and ways of life back then.