First Time I Saw You Cry

I sit alone in the dark
Reminiscing this painful day
Tears well up in my eyes
Each drop falling on my face

You told me you never loved me
That you never even cared
But how could you say that when
Yesterday you said we're the perfect pair

The things that you said today
Left anguish in my broken heart
It felt like something pierced right through
Like millions of flying darts

But why was it that when you said it
I saw pain and tears in your eyes
If it's true that you didn't love me
Then why did I see you cry?