Comments : A Melodious Failure

  • 18 years ago

    by Bill Turner

    I like this poem, but if it were me, I would simplify it. I have an English degree and I had to stop and think what some of the words meant, which disrupted the flow. Hemingway was successful because he wrote in a direct style. Shakespears plays appealed to the common man, even the histories. Something to consider. Not everyone operates on your linguistic level.

  • 18 years ago

    by rbmo401

    I really liked it. it was definetly alittle over exagerated at times, bu ti feel that it added to the meaning and complete feeling that it puts out. sometimes it was hard to follow but in most of it you were dead on. I really liked::
    "The taste and smell of death
    Have filled the sterile, lifeless earth
    Where desolate silhouettes roam with no purpose.
    Inhospitable Loneliness is no longer subject to chance"

  • 18 years ago

    by Lu

    I agree alot with Bill ...
    Except I didn't have to stop and think what some of the words meant ....I had to stop to look them up for their meaning ..LOL
    Which got me a little lost and confused..
    Very impressive I'm sure to the overly intelligent mind ....but to this simple mind it was very (puzzling).....
    Anyways sorry I'm not much help but I'm off to read some of your other poems ....
    Dang !!! I hate it when those half my age are more intelligent than me or is it I .....English definately wasn't my major ..hehe ~Hugs sweets~

  • 18 years ago

    by Fighter (Ariane L.)

    Wow.. you certainly have a very wide vocabulary... but amazing poem, as always. you're extremely talented. keep it up!
    -xXx-

  • 18 years ago

    by Gesselle Valle

    Como siempre tus poemas son muy buenos. Escribeme y te embiare mi nuevo nombre...para que leas mis poemas...5/5 great poem and keep it up.

  • 18 years ago

    by shadowlight

    Fantastic poem. the wide vocabulary used ensured a lack of repition which you so often find.

    5/5 well done

  • 18 years ago

    by Feline Fatigue

    May also try, and fail, their love to hold
    Knowing not that all such attempts are vain,
    I think you should re-write these two lines. I understand it, but it can't hold up the poem, if you know what I mean.
    Laugh at the one who loved and lost his stance.
    You should shorten that up a bit or re-write it.
    appalling
    It's a good word, but it doesn't go well in the poem in this case. Try an alternet word.
    Over-all, another strong, meaningful poem. Bravo. But this time I must give a 4/5, because of a few bumps and bruises as I read it.

  • 18 years ago

    by LonelyNightsHurt

    You are an AWESOME writer, and im still waitin on the one you said you'd write for me...lol...love brittany

  • 18 years ago

    by Allison

    That was really deep. I thought it had a nice flow to it. Keep up the good work. *5/5*