First & The Other

I didn't think that it was possible to fall in love with two people
Especially not at the same time
But now I have
I believe that anything is possible

One, I know, as well as myself
And he knows me too
The other, a mystery still
One that I want to figure out

I went with one
But yearned for the other
Now I'm with the other
But yearning for the first

How is it so
That I can not be satisfied
No matter which I'm with
I always want the other

I love them both
The first and the other
Not the same
But in very different ways

But now I face my final choice
Do I stay with the first
Or give it all for the other
And risk losing them both?