5 years ago
I posted this at the end of her thread but now I'm interested in developing this idea if Janis ever returns.
First, what do you think of it?
Second, if you like it, what would you put for the follow-up selections for each of the votes 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5?
I think a two part vote might be an improvement.
First you vote 1 through 5,
Then depending on your vote you are given the option to select a choice that gives feedback.
Say you hit 5.
You are asked to choose (for example)
__ poem is original
__ poem is emotional
__ poem is thought provoking
__ poem is (etcetera)
Or you hit 3
__ poem needs grammatical help
__ poem needs structure
__ poem needs continuity
And so forth
A necessary change is the ability to change your vote if the author changes the poem. That is, if you vote "3" & select that the poem needs structure, and the author then revises the poem correcting that issue, you should be able to change your vote to a "5" if you wish.